India needs a Thinking Culture
By Anurag Batra
In the land that gave birth to the great Buddha and Aryabhata, it is baffling to see the paucity and lack of acceptance of thinkers, who in fact have the capability to endow and enrich the fabric of our society.
“Thinkers are original. Thinkers contribute a fresh angle or a fresh perspective or a never thought of before approach to, fundamental aspects of our lives and humanity.”
“India is facing so many dilemmas; only sustained, systematic thinking followed by action can make sure India and Indians realise their dreams.”
“You and I are not what we eat; we are what we think. ” said Walter Anderson in The Confidence Course, 1997
When I was in business school almost 20 years ago, there was this saying or shall I say quip, “Those who can do, do and become managers and entrepreneurs, those who cannot do become teachers, and those who cannot do and cannot teach become consultants .”
Can we say the same about thinkers ? What are the similarities between thinkers and consultants ?
When I was part of the management consulting team of my business school the joke about consultants was, consultants are people whom when you ask the time, they look at your watch, tell you the time and take the watch away. Thinkers are not the same. Thinkers are original. Thinkers contribute a fresh angle or a fresh perspective or a never thought of before approach to, fundamental aspects of our lives and humanity. Thinkers dare I say, change the world.
We in India do not encourage thinkers and the thinking culture because to sustain thinkers we need to give them an environment where they can blossom by challenging existing paradigms; where they are left alone and allowed to experiment. Thinkers are like R&D heads at pharma companies; sometimes it takes them a lot of time to find their eureka moments.
When you think of a thinker, you think of an erudite person, with a beard, sipping tea and reclining in his chair or leaning forward on his table and in a “thought mudra”.
India is facing so many dilemmas; only sustained, systematic thinking followed by action can make sure India and Indians realise their dreams. The words of Voltaire have never rung more true, than they do today: No problem can withstand the assault of sustained thinking.
The Indian government and our great institutions have to encourage the thinking culture. What is a thinking culture ? In my view the thinking culture is where very exceptionally talented professionals from various walks of life are left to do their own thing without expecting much. It’s like drug discovery. The thinking culture nurtures contrarian and sometimes impractical ideas. The thinking culture encourages individuals to think of ideas that may not be practical at first glance.
Let’s do a reality check. How many think tanks exist in India? Do we institutionally provide funding to think tanks? The answers to both will be bleak at best. We have to stop looking at think tanks and thinkers as irritants or people challenging the status quo. We have to make thinkers the starting point of our plans, our ideation, and our futuristic goals. When will that happen in India? In the land of Buddha and the land of Aryabhata.
Whichever way you look at it, we need more thinkers in India. When I think of thinkers, I think of the following words:
“…the thoughtful excitement of lonely rambles, of gardening, and of other like occupations, where the mind has leisure to must during the healthful activity of the body, with the fresh and wakeful breezes blowing round it…” said Augustus William Hare and Julius Charles Hare, Guesses at Truth, by Two Brothers, 1827
Are institutions and authorities afraid of thinkers in India? In my view involving thinkers in governance would lead to better governance. “Men fear thought as they fear nothing else on earth, more than ruin, more even than death. Thought is subversive and revolutionary, destructive and terrible, thought is merciless to privilege, established institutions, and comfortable habit. Thought looks into the pit of hell and is not afraid. Thought is great and swift and free, the light of the world, and the chief glory of man.” said Bertrand Russell
Some of the thinkers quoted were great doers also, they visualised and they achieved. It is said, “Thinkers think and doers do. But until the thinkers do and the doers think, progress will be just another word in the already overburdened vocabulary of the talkers who talk”. The Thinkers50 is a celebration of ideas, of action led movements, and individuals whose thoughts will shape the future of India.
The author an entrepreneur, media observer and a journalist rolled into one. He is a B. Tech in Computer Sciences, a degree, which he acquired before joining Management Development Institute (MDI), Gurgaon, one of India’s leading Business School. Batra is the Managing Director and Editor-in-Chief of exchange4media group which includes exchange4media.com, PITCH, IMPACT, Realty Plus and Franchise Plus.